Cannabis in the Clinic? The Medical Marijuana Debate The Debate

Until its prohibition in 1937, extract of Cannabis sativa (marijuana) was one of the top three most prescribed medicines in the US. When it became illegal, its use as a medicine became restricted. Despite these regulations research on the medical use of marijuana continued.

In recent years, when some states decided to legalize smoked marijuana for certain patients, medical marijuana became a subject of contentious debate. Should patients be allowed to grow their own plants? Might medical use inevitably lead to recreational use?

Marijuana Is Medicine Sign

Listen to our complete medical marijuana podcast.

Receptors

Immune System (thymus)

CB2 Cannabinoid Receptor

T-cells

Brain

CB1 Cannabinoid Receptor

There are two types of cannabinoid receptors in the body. CB1 receptors are expressed on the surface of neurons, and CB2 receptors are expressed on cells of the immune system.

The Endocannabinoid System

The active compounds in marijuana are similar to a class of molecules in our bodies called endocannabinoids. Both bind to receptors in the brain and throughout the body called cannabinoid receptors. This system influences our immune system, protects nerve cells from premature death, and influences mood, memory, appetite, sleep and movement.

Dr. Robert Melamede

"Endocannabinoids regulate every one of the systems in our bodies."

Cannabinoids

Marijuana contains approximately 66 active compounds with different properties, collectively called cannabinoids. Scientists are currently studying cannabinoids in an effort to understand their individual and combined effects, and their potential benefits.

Who Can Benefit?

Research and anecdotal evidence suggest that there are conditions for which medical marijuana may be the most effective treatment.

"There are different kinds of pain."

Cancer - Relieves nausea during chemotherapy treatment.

AIDS - Increases appetite in patients experiencing severe weight loss.

Neurological disorders (including spinal cord injury and multiple sclerosis) - Reduces pain and spasticity resulting from nerve damage.

Inflammatory pain - Cannabinoids seem to be more effective than opiates in treating long-term, chronic pain (opiates are better for treating short-term acute pain).

Autoimmune diseases (such as arthritis) - Suppresses the immune system resulting in less pain and inflammation.

Dr. Robert Melamede

Cannabinoid Delivery Methods

The active compounds in marijuana are available in several forms, and can be administered in a variety of ways. Each delivery method has its own benefits and disadvantages.

Pipe Defining Medical Marijuana

In 1970, Congress classified cannabis and THC (one of the active compounds in cannabis) as Schedule I drugs under the Controlled Substances Act. Schedule I drugs are defined by Congress as having no medicinal value. The one exception to this classification allows for use in FDA-approved research programs.

US Map

VT

ME

DC

RI

WA

CO

MT

OR

HI

AK

NV

CA

As of January, 2006, 11 states and the District of Columbia have legalized medical marijuana. Each state has its own regulations to control details such as allowable quantities and registration requirements. However, in June of 2005, the Supreme Court ruled that individuals in all states can still be prosecuted under federal law, under which medical marijuana remains illegal under the Controlled Substances Act.

Smoking marijuana

Positive

Delivers all of the plant's active compounds.

Positive

Easy to regulate dose (patients smoke until symptoms are eased, but are not intoxicated).

Negative

No standardization. Amounts of active ingredients may vary.

Positive

Burning marijuana produces toxins which can cause emphysema and lung cancer.

Positive

Illegal in most states.

Marinol

Marinol - Synthetic THC in pill form.

Positive

Legal in US.

Positive

Delivers some of the benefits of marijuana.

Negative

Difficult to control dose.

Positive

Contains only one of the plant's active compounds (THC). Patients report fewer of the positive effects associated with marijuana, with more negative side effects.

Vaporizer

Vaporizor - Converts the active compounds in marijuana to inhalable form, without releasing toxins.

Positive

Delivers all of the plant's active compounds.

Positive

Easy to control dose.

Negative

No standardization. Amounts of active ingredients may vary.

Positive

Illegal in most states.

Sativex

Sativex - Extract from cloned marijuana plants delivered as a spray.

Positive

Contains all of the plant’s active compounds.

Positive

Concentrations of active ingredients are standardized.

Positive

Relatively easy to regulate dose.

Positive

Legal only in Canada and the UK. Clinical trials are under way in the US for treatment of Multiple Sclerosis.

Social Implications

If medical marijuana were legalized in all states, there might be repercussions outside the realm of medicine. Opponents worry that legalizing medical marijuana might lead teens to believe that marijuana is safe for recreational use and increase availability of the drug. On the other hand, some supporters think changing the perception of marijuana from a party drug to a medication might make it less attractive to teens wanting to defy or rebel.

"Studies show that Sativex (marijuana extract) is not as addicting as legal prescription medications such as opiates."

Dr. William Notcutt,
director of Sativex trials

Girl with a Bong

Opponents worry that medical marijuana might lead more teens to use marijuana recreationally.

Capitol Hill

Some argue that Congress should change marijuana's classification under the Controlled Substances Act. If it were no longer a Schedule I drug, its medicinal benefits could be recognized legally. But opponents fear that legalizing marijuana for medicinal purposes would open the door to its legalization for recreational use.

Legal Implications

Legalized medical marijuana also presents law enforcement with challenges. How would federal, state and local governments control and regulate the production, distribution and sale of medical marijuana? Who would define what is recreational versus medical use of the drug, and how would that be enforced?